New iPods might be a letdown, but this ad isn’t
Friday, September 26th, 2008 | Posted by Ryan La RosaI’m about to say two things that are probably going to be very unpopular around the office: I’m not an “Apple” guy, and I’m not all that keen on advertising. Before there’s a “here we go again” moment — since I bashed my own field of PR a few weeks back, let me once again explain.
I get Apple. I get that they’re innovators. I have an iPod. But I’m not going to drive around with the sticker on my car. They just don’t excite me as much as some people. As for advertising, I think it can make a tremendous impact, but that doesn’t usually happen. The vast majority of ads are stale and contrived and I’m continually amazed that they make it through agency and client approvals.
That being said, the marriage of these two things just sparked something that I’m comfortable saying is the best advertisement I have seen in years. Every day I read The New York Times online, and never once have I clicked on, let alone noticed, an ad on the site. But today, as I was reading the front-page article, that changed.
I couldn’t help but be drawn to the right side of the page and the blaring headline “Stop Switching to Mac!” as written by PC. The copy focuses on PC’s deficiencies and asks that PC’s once loyal customers stick with it, ensuring them that eventually they’d turn it around. Of course the ad bashes Mac, as well, asking whether customers have gotten sick of all the Mac superlatives. I saw all of this even before I discovered there was sound and visuals bringing in the now famous Mac and PC personalities to narrate. 
A lot of money? Of course. It must have cost a ton to keep that ad up there all day. But before everyone says that if they had Apple’s budget they could create something as clever and effective, let me say that this ad’s effectiveness has more to do with message than with budget. This is what happens when the first thing asked in a creative meeting is “How can we get people talking?” It’s a simple approach, but one rarely taken. Usually the first question asked is “How do we spend this money?”
When the focus is switched to buzz and conversations, you can see the results. It’s clear that Apple worked across departments to achieve this ad’s effectiveness. Media planners and buyers who think their job is all about numbers and not creativity need look no further than this ad for inspiration.
I still don’t love Apple, and until they create something that allows me to download warm, soft, chocolate chip cookies, I probably never will. But I have to hand it to them for providing us with a real life, real-time case study on what advertising is all about.



The “
